Compare
Dumpster vs. Home Depot dump trailer: what it really costs
Renting a dump trailer yourself can look cheap until you add the tow, the landfill fees, and the paperwork. Here is our delivered 15-yard dump trailer next to Home Depot's largest one, with the numbers on the table.
For a rental of 3 days or more, our all-in price is about 53% of Home Depot's: $470 vs. $890.51. That's for a trailer with twice the capacity, delivered and hauled away, with 2 tons of disposal included.
Home Depot's total includes its optional damage protection and 8% sales tax, and leaves out the landfill fees you'd pay yourself. Home Depot figures checked October 5, 2026.
Same footprint, twice the trailer
Both trailers are 7 feet wide and 14 feet long. The difference is the walls, the weight limit, and who does the work.
| Feature | Big Skye 15-yard dump trailer | Home Depot's largest dump trailer |
|---|---|---|
| Footprint | 7' x 14' | 7' x 14' |
| Wall height | 4' | 2' |
| Capacity | 14.52 cubic yards | 7.26 cubic yards |
| Maximum weight rating | 14,000 lb | 5,800 lb |
| Disposal | 2 tons included, $65/ton after that | Not included. You haul it to the landfill and pay there. |
| Delivery and pickup | Included | You tow it yourself |
We also bring a 16-foot version of the same trailer when it fits your job better, at the same price: 7' x 16' x 4', about 16.59 cubic yards, 16,000 lb maximum weight rating. Home Depot specs are from its website.
What it costs
Our numbers are live from this site. Home Depot's are a Jacksonville-area store's estimated rates on October 5, 2026, and they can change. We compare a full day or more.
| Cost | Big Skye dump trailer | Home Depot, 1 day | Home Depot, 3 days to a week |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rental | $450 (3–5 day rental) | $239 | $717 (3 days costs the same as the week) |
| Fuel surcharge | $20 flat | None listed | None listed |
| Damage protection (optional, 15%) | No add-on | $35.85 | $107.55 |
| Sales tax | None on dumpster rentals | 8%: $21.99 | 8%: $65.96 |
| All-in total | $470 | $296.84 | $890.51 |
| All-in without the optional protection | $470 | $258.12 | $774.36 |
| Landfill fees | Included for 2 tons | You pay, by the ton | You pay, by the ton |
| Towing, driving, and fuel for the tow | We deliver and pick up | You | You |
- Paying by card? Our 2.99% card service fee adds $14.05, for $484.05 (still about 54% of Home Depot's weekly all-in). The fee applies to credit card, Apple Pay, Google Pay, and PayPal payments.
- Over 2 tons? Extra weight is $65 a ton. Even 3 tons over ($195), our total would be $665.
- Skip Home Depot's protection? You take on the damage risk yourself (see the agreement summary below).
Dump fees: who pays?
With our rental, disposal of the first 2 tons is included. If you haul it yourself, the landfill charges by the ton.
| County | General waste | Construction and demolition | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Baker | $30 | $30 | Florida DEP 2025 |
| Bradford | $30 | $30 | Florida DEP 2025 |
| Duval | $30.30 | $22.71 | Florida DEP 2025 |
| Clay | $70 to $78 | $70 to $84Depends on who is hauling (franchise or non-franchise). | Clay County |
| Alachua | $65 | Not accepted at county sitesAlachua County says construction debris is no longer accepted at its drop-off sites. | Florida DEP 2025 |
| St. Johns | $67.26 | Set by the facilityThe county lists $67.26 as its commercial rate. It requires construction debris to go to a designated facility (St. Marks C&D Disposal Facility or the Waste Pro transfer station) and does not publish that rate. | St. Johns County |
| Nassau | $45 at Sandhill Recycle Center in Yulee, a private facilityNassau County does not publish a landfill rate. Call Sandhill at (904) 225-2801 to confirm. | Sandhill Recycle Center, per Big Skye | |
These are the current rates we could confirm. In the counties we serve they run from about $22.71 to $84 per ton. Clay County also charges $85.50 to $91.50 for waste that comes from outside the county.
The 2 tons our rental includes would cost you roughly $45.42 to $168 in landfill fees if you hauled it yourself.
Checked October 5, 2026. Fees change and vary by facility, so confirm with the landfill you would use. Sources: Florida DEP, 2025 Solid Waste Disposal Fees,Clay County solid waste disposal fees, St. Johns County garbage drop-off fees, and Alachua County's Environmental Park page.
Is Home Depot ever cheaper?
Sometimes, yes. For a small, light, one-day project, if you have a vehicle that can tow a trailer and you don't mind the landfill run, a one-day Home Depot rental can come in under our flat price. Here is the one-day math with dump fees added:
| Your load | Home Depot, 1 day, with dump fees | Big Skye, all-in |
|---|---|---|
| 1 ton | $319.55 to $380.84 | $470 |
| 2 tons (what ours includes) | $342.26 to $464.84 | $470 |
Dump fees run from the lowest to the highest published rate in the counties we serve ($22.71 to $84 per ton). Home Depot's total includes its optional protection and 8% tax. None of it counts your tow vehicle's fuel, your time, or the drive.
But check the capacity before you decide:
- Their trailer holds 7.26 cubic yards with 2-foot walls. Ours holds 14.52. A load that fills our trailer is about two trips in theirs, and every extra trip is another drive and another dump fee.
- Bulky loads, like furniture or yard debris, run out of room before they run out of weight. Heavy loads use up the weight limit sooner: 5,800 lb in theirs, 14,000 lb in ours.
- A longer or bigger job moves Home Depot to its weekly rate ($890.51 all-in), where our flat price is far lower.
What a Home Depot rental agreement puts on you
This is a standard equipment-rental agreement. But renting a trailer for a weekend project means taking on more responsibility than most people read closely. This is our summary, in our words, of the Equipment and Vehicle Rental Agreement text we reviewed on October 5, 2026. Read the current agreement before you rent.
- Damage risk is yours. You're responsible for loss or damage to the trailer regardless of fault, including ordinary wear, unless you buy the optional damage protection. Even the protection leaves out misuse, neglect, and theft.
- Upkeep is yours. You're required to check fluid and fuel levels and do routine inspections during the rental.
- Liability is yours. You take on the risks of having and operating the equipment, and agree to cover Home Depot against claims that come out of the rental.
- Returning it late can be a legal problem. The agreement points to Florida's rental-property law (section 812.155), which treats failing to return hired equipment after a formal demand, or not paying what's owed, as evidence of abandonment. Depending on the value, it can be a misdemeanor or a felony.
- No warranty. The equipment is provided "as is."
- Georgia law applies, even for a rental in Florida.
- It's tracked. The equipment has GPS, and its location and use can be tracked.
With a Big Skye rental, we own the equipment, its upkeep, and the trip to the landfill.
Questions people ask
How much does it cost to rent a dumpster vs. a Home Depot dump trailer?
For a rental of 3 days or more, our delivered 15-yard dump trailer is $470 all-in: the $450 rental plus the current $20 fuel surcharge, with 2 tons of disposal included. Home Depot's 7' x 14' dump trailer at its weekly rate is about $890.51 with its optional damage protection and 8% sales tax, plus landfill fees you pay yourself. Prices are as of October 5, 2026, and Home Depot's can change.
Is it cheaper to rent a dump trailer from Home Depot?
It can be for a small, light, one-day project if you have a vehicle that can tow it: a one-day Home Depot rental is about $296.84 all-in, plus landfill fees by the ton. But their trailer holds 7.26 cubic yards to our 14.52, so a bigger load takes extra trips and extra dump fees, and a rental of 3 days or more moves to their weekly rate.
How much does the Home Depot dump trailer hold?
Home Depot's largest dump trailer is 7' x 14' with 2-foot walls, about 7.26 cubic yards, with a 5,800 lb maximum weight rating. Our 15-yard dump trailer is 7' x 14' with 4-foot walls, about 14.52 cubic yards, with a 14,000 lb maximum weight rating.
What's included in a Big Skye dump trailer rental?
Delivery, pickup, and 2 tons of disposal, for a 3–5 day rental. Weight over 2 tons is $65 per ton. A flat fuel surcharge ($20 now) is shown as its own line, and no sales tax is added to dumpster rentals. Need the trailer longer than 5 days? Ask us for a quote.
Home Depot prices and specifications are from a Jacksonville-area Home Depot's website on October 5, 2026. They are estimates and can change. Big Skye Dumpsters is not affiliated with or endorsed by The Home Depot, and Home Depot is a trademark of its owner. Landfill fees: Florida DEP, 2025 Solid Waste Disposal Fees, and Clay County's published schedule.
Reserve online or call. We'll confirm size, date, and price. See all sizes and pricing.